“A written agreement is not the absence of conflict but the ability to manage conflict.”
Disclaimer: This is not legal advice.
From sealing multimillion-pound business deals to hiring a contractor for home renovations, having a written contract in place is paramount. Yet, the importance of written contracts often goes underestimated or misunderstood.
Dispelling Misconceptions
Oral Agreements Suffice: While oral agreements can be legally binding in certain circumstances, they are notoriously difficult to enforce. Without written documentation to corroborate the terms of the agreement, disputes can easily arise, leading to costly legal battles and potential loss of rights.
Written Contracts Must Be Elaborate: While complexity may be warranted in certain contexts, a well-crafted contract focuses on clarity, outlining the terms and expectations in plain language accessible to all parties involved. A concise and straightforward contract not only facilitates mutual understanding but also enhances enforceability by reducing the likelihood of disputes over interpretation.
Written Contracts Are Only Necessary for Major Transactions: Even seemingly minor agreements can give rise to significant disputes if the parties’ expectations are not clearly defined and documented. By formalising the terms of the agreement in a written contract, parties can mitigate risks, protect their rights, and establish a foundation for a successful transactional relationship.
Standard Templates are Adequate: While standard contract templates can provide a useful starting point, they may lead to oversights, loopholes, and unintended consequences. It is advisable to tailor the contract to the specific needs and objectives of the parties involved, taking into account the nature of the transaction, relevant legal requirements, and potential risks.
Real-World Example
Precarious Start
Sarah, a freelance graphic designer, is approached by a startup company to create a logo for their new brand. Sarah and the startup’s founder, John, discuss the project over the phone and agree on a price of £7,000 for the logo design, with a deadline of two weeks. However, they fail to formalise their agreement in writing.
Project Completion
Sarah diligently works on the logo, investing time and resources to deliver a high-quality design within the agreed-upon timeframe.
Payment Dispute
Upon receiving the completed logo, John expresses dissatisfaction, claiming that the design does not align with his vision for the brand. He not only refuses to pay Sarah the agreed-upon £7,000 but also states that he no longer wants her services.
Seeking Legal Advice
Feeling unfairly treated, Sarah decides to seek legal advice to understand her rights and options. She contacts several lawyers to discuss her situation and understand whether she has a legal basis to pursue payment for her work.
Negotiation Attempts
Sarah’s lawyer advises her to try to resolve the matter amicably with John before escalating it to court. They draft a formal demand letter outlining Sarah’s position and requesting the full payment as per their verbal agreement.
Court Proceedings
Despite Sarah’s efforts to resolve the dispute outside of court, John remains adamant and refuses to pay the full amount. With no written contract to substantiate her claim, Sarah decides to file a lawsuit against the startup company for breach of contract.
Legal Battle
The case proceeds to court, where both parties present their arguments and evidence. Without a written contract to provide clear terms and evidence of the agreed-upon price and deadline, Sarah’s case becomes more challenging to prove.
Key Takeaways
∞ A well-drafted contract would have clearly outlined the terms of the agreement, including the scope of work, payment amount, deadline, and any provisions for revisions or disputes.
∞ By formalising their agreement in writing, Sarah and John could have avoided misunderstandings and legal disputes,thereby safeguarding not only their mental and financial well-being but also preventing the misspending of valuable time.
∞ Such proactive measures would have not only preserved their professional rapport but also averted the unnecessary strain and stress that ensued.
Essential Elements of a Contract:
- Identification of Parties: Clearly identify all
parties involved in the
agreement, including their legal names and contact information. You must ensure that the parties to the
contract exist and they are whom they say they are.
The contract should include a representation section in which all parties confirm the accuracy and truthfulness of the information provided during negotiations and contract formation. This clause typically includes warranties and assurances regarding various aspects of the transaction, such as the parties’ authority to enter into the agreement, the absence of undisclosed liabilities or disputes, and the validity of any documents or information exchanged. - Clear Language and Timelines: Use clear and concise language to avoid ambiguity and misinterpretation, and establish specific deadlines or timelines for deliverables. Consider including provisions to define key words and expressions used in the contract.
- Offer and Acceptance: Outline the specific terms and conditions of the agreement, including what goods or services will be provided, the timeline for delivery, and the payment terms.
- Consideration: Specify what each party will receive in exchange for fulfilling their obligations under the contract. This could be monetary compensation, goods, services, promises to do or not do something, or anything else of value that induces the parties to enter into the contract. In simpler terms, consideration is what makes the contract binding and distinguishes it from a mere gift or donation.
- Mutual Consent: Ensure that all parties voluntarily agree to the terms of the contract without coercion or duress.
- Legal Purpose and Implementation: Confirm that the purpose of the contract is lawful and does not violate any laws or regulations, and that the methods employed to achieve that purpose are also legally sound.
- Law and Jurisdiction: This clause establishes the legal framework that governs the contract and determines which court or legal system has authority over any disputes that may arise. Failure to do so may lead to jurisdictional conflicts, where different courts claim authority over the dispute. This can result in prolonged legal battles, increased costs, and uncertainty about the outcome.
- Limitation of liability: Include provisions that limit each party’s liability under the contract, protecting them from excessive financial risk in case of unforeseen circumstances or breaches of contract.
- Termination: Outline the conditions under which either party can terminate the contract, including notice periods and any associated penalties or consequences.
- Indemnity: Including an indemnity clause in your contract can provide added protection by allocating risk between the parties. An indemnity clause typically stipulates that one party agrees to compensate the other for losses, damages, or liabilities arising from specified events or circumstances. Common indemnities may include indemnity for breach, indemnity for third-party claims, and indemnity for intellectual property infringement.
- Force Majeure: Identify unforeseeable events, often called ‘acts of God,’ that could hinder contract fulfillment. These include natural disasters, government actions, or war declarations. Recent events like COVID-19 underscore the need to clarify how such events will be managed, especially if not initially identified in the agreement.
Bonus Clauses to Elevate Your Agreement
- Entire Agreement: This clause states that the contract represents the entire agreement between the parties and supersedes any prior agreements or understandings, whether oral or written. It helps to prevent disputes over additional terms or promises not included in the written contract.
- Severability: This clause stipulates that if any provision of the contract is found to be invalid or unenforceable, the remaining provisions will remain in full force and effect. It ensures that the contract remains enforceable to the greatest extent possible, even if certain provisions are deemed invalid by a court.
- Dispute resolution clause: Consider including a clause outlining alternative dispute resolution methods such as mediation, arbitration, and negotiation, which can help parties resolve conflicts more efficiently and cost-effectively than traditional litigation. These alternative methods offer several benefits, including faster resolution times, lower costs, and greater flexibility in finding mutually acceptable solutions.
- Amendment: This clause outlines the procedure for making changes or amendments to the contract. It typically requires any amendments to be made in writing and signed by all parties to the contract, helping to prevent misunderstandings or disputes over changes to the agreement.
- Assignment: This clause governs whether the parties are allowed to assign their rights or delegate their obligations under the contract to third parties. It helps to clarify the rights and responsibilities of the parties and prevent unauthorised transfers of contractual obligations.
-
Confidentiality Clause: This clause ensures that sensitive information shared between parties remains confidential and is not disclosed to any third party without explicit consent.
When should you not enter into a contract?
- You have strong doubts about your counter-party’s reliability. A well-drafted contract cannot recoup the lost time, energy, and costs, nor can it alleviate the stress and headaches caused by dealing with unreliable partners, often resulting in a domino effect of contractual challenges.
- You do not understand the terms of the contract. If you ask the party for clarification and you understand their explanation, request for that explanation to replace the words in the written contract.
- You feel pressured or disadvantaged. Remember, entering into a contract should always be a mutually beneficial decision, and no party should feel coerced or unfairly treated in the process. If your counter-party is pressuring you into signing a contract hastily or presenting terms that seem unfair or unclear, politely express your concerns and reassess the situation carefully. In moments like this, it is important to have someone to speak to.
Rule of thumb
If the other party is unwilling to address your concerns or engage in open dialogue, it may be a red flag indicating potential issues with the proposed agreement. Trust your instincts and prioritise your own well-being and interests above all else.
Golden Rule: Always Document Everything
Keep detailed records of all communications, negotiations, and agreements related to the contract. Written documentation can serve as valuable evidence in the event of disputes or legal proceedings.
Conclusion
Contracts serve as vital tools to protect interests and prevent potential losses in transactions. However, it is essential to recognise that imposing written contracts in certain relationships can strain trust and rapport. It is about finding the right approach to introduce the concept in a manner that resonates with your counter-party, fostering open communication and active listening. Guide them to a point where they see the value in formalising agreements, perceiving it not as a hindrance but as a pathway to mutual growth and success.